Home Blog Page 268

Paddler Advocates are Back with a Vengeance

Reflections: Paddler Advocates are Back with a Vengeance | Protest like it's 1993. Photo: Ray Smith / Times Colonist

Sea kayaking has always been strong on tradition. Paddlers revive old Inuit techniques, build boats from designs in museums, and retrace long-ago expeditions. But we have another important tradition that we neglected until recently: being a force for conservation.

In 1954, a paddler and retired chemistry professor named Harold Bradley teamed up with a group of river runners to save the Yampa River from dams in what is now Dinosaur National Monument. The campaign transformed a modest outdoor club into a household name in conservation: they’re called the Sierra Club. A decade later, river guide Martin Litton led a campaign to keep dams out of the Grand Canyon.

More recently, in 1993, sea kayakers joined forces with environmentalists and First Nations to save Vancouver Island’s Clayoquot Sound from wholesale logging. The protests marked the largest act of civil disobedience in the nation’s history, and preserved what is now one of the world’s best-known paddling meccas.

Then conservation abruptly disappeared from the paddling community’s agenda. Kayakers turned inward, focusing narrowly on the sport. In 2006, I was even told by a local paddling club that I couldn’t make an announcement about a campaign to protect natural areas, because it might be “divisive.”

Why the retreat? Ironically, one reason was success. Led by the likes of Litton, Bradley, David Brower and Edward Abbey, with roots firmly in outdoor exploration, the first wave of conservation won major victories in the ‘60s and ‘70s. Those victories created environmental laws that relied on science and legal action for enforcement. The need was suddenly for ecologists and lawyers who could appeal timber sales, file Clean Water Act suits, and protest obscure agency procedures.

About the same time, the sport of kayaking was growing and manufacturers and clubs found themselves maneuvering for customers and members. In this increasingly competitive environment, many feared alienating one side of the conservation debate.

After a two-decade hiatus, however, kayakers are re-embracing the art of advocacy. Conservation groups reached the limit of what they could achieve through law and science alone, and returned to mobilizing passionate people. In Portland, paddlers made headlines in 2012 by arranging their crafts into a giant “350” on the river (the amount of carbon dioxide the atmosphere can tolerate without cataclysm). From student Anna Gleizer’s 2012 circumnavigation of Siberia’s Lake Baikal to study water quality and climate effects, to the Sitka Conservation Society’s trips to survey wilderness areas and watchdog timber sales, paddling and advocacy have merged once more.

Reflections: Paddler Advocates are Back with a Vengeance | Protest like it’s 1993. Photo: Ray Smith / Times Colonist

We’ve also made the leap from raising awareness and collecting data to the hard-nosed work of changing policy. Letters and emails from paddlers helped shift the Forest Service from logging toward wilderness protection in Alaska and pushed a river-mining moratorium in Oregon.

Modern paddler-activists have another powerful tool at our disposal: the technological democracy of the Internet. One example is Out of Sight, Out of Mind, a marine debris campaign created on the cheap by kayak instructors using Facebook and Kickstarter.

In the next few years, I predict that kayakers’ resurgent conservation ethic will find the sweet spot between freewheeling awareness-raising and more coordinated strategies needed to create marine reserves, regulate pollution and pressure policymakers.

Back in British Columbia, paddlers of all stripes are once again on the frontlines of a pivotal battle. The stakes are every bit as high as in ‘93: the Enbridge Northern Gateway pipeline to Kitimat would transform the wild Central Coast into a tanker freeway vulnerable to a Valdez-size oil spill. The lost tradition has returned just in time.

Longtime contributor Neil Schulman celebrates kayaking’s diverse heritage in Reflections.


This article first appeared in the Spring 2015 issue of Adventure Kayak magazine. Subscribe to Paddling Magazine and get 25 years of digital magazine archives including our legacy titles: Rapid, Adventure Kayak and Canoeroots.

3 Tricks For Great Audio With Your Action Camera

Man kayaking and wearing GoPro on his hlmet
Take your adventure videos to the next level by recording higher-quality audio.

The popularity of action cameras is steadily increasing, as are the number of action videos on the web. However, a very important part of the video-making process is being neglected by both manufacturers and consumers alike.

Over the last couple of years I’ve gained experience in audio recording while making my sea kayak films, but the methods presented in this article are applicable in any situation where you want crisp monologue despite the hostile environment. “Plug and play” waterproof audio solutions don’t exist, but in this article I’ll show you three different setups I’ve come up with.

The three waterproof audio recorder setups all require you record the audio separately and sync it with the lesser-quality audio recorded on your action cam.

The setups are:

1. Recorder in a condom

Audio recorder in condom

A rather cheap and versatile option is to seal a normal audio recorder in a condom. I use the popular Zoom H1 Stereo Recorder, but this trick applies to any audio recorder that’ll fit in a condom.

The thin yet tough membrane of the condom allows most of the audio waves through, and the device can still be operated as usual. Although this article mainly focuses on monologue, this recorder also works really well for recording ambient sounds.

How to use

  • Clean the condom of any lubricants with a paper towel
  • Roll the condom on and tie a knot
  • Apply the windscreen and you are ready to clap (to make syncing audio easier later)
  • When outdoors, always use a fur/windscreen to avoid wind noise. In my experience the Redhead windscreen is the best option for the Zoom H1 recorder.
  • Keep the windscreen dry and bring a spare
  • Tie a lanyard to the recorder

Pros

  • Economical
  • 10 hours of recording time on a AA battery
  • Small
  • Versatile
  • Surprisingly durable
  • Fast setup

Cons

  • Plastic cabinet picks up noise
  • Can’t monitor audio with headphones when condom is on
  • Condom blocks the highest frequencies
  • Condom can rip open
  • More prone to pick up wind noise
[ Paddling Buyer’s Guide: View all electronics for paddling ]

2. Waterproof lavalier microphone

Audio recorder in waterproof bag

This setup gives you a lot better audio quality but will cost you almost the same as your action cam. It’s a combination of the VT500 Water from Voice Technologies—a waterproof lavalier (lapel) mic that can withstand temporary submersion— and the Zoom H1 recorder—kept dry in a drybag from Aquapac, which can also take a short plunge.

How to use

  • The Aquapac has a special watertight opening that allows cables to run through, for use with waterproof earphones to monitor the audio
  • The input level in the Zoom H1 should be set at 30 to 40
  • The microphone can be positioned with a clip about 20 to 30 cm beneath the talent’s mouth. In some cases I have used PVC tape to secure the mic to the PFD.
  • In my experience, it’s best to keep everything ready in a watertight box and as soon as you’ve finished recording, return everything to the box. This way you’ll keep the fur dry and the cables protected from any mishap.
  • Always use a fur/windscreen on the mic and bear in mind that the audio recording will be useless if the fur gets wet—so always bring some spares. I use the ones from Rycote when working with lavalier mics and then tie an elastic band around the bottom of the fur to avoid losing it should I go overboard!

Pros

  • Good audio quality
  • Waterproof
  • Durable microphone picks up less wind noise

Cons

  • More costly
  • Takes time to set up

3. Smartphone with lavalier microphone

Smartphone in waterproof bag.

This setup is not entirely waterproof, but will give you good audio results at a fairly cheap price. The combination is similar to the example above, but your smartphone is used as the recorder and kept safe in a smaller Aquapac. The microphone is a Røde Smart Lav+.

This lavalier is designed for smartphones and gives you really decent sound at a very reasonable price. Also, the fur that fits this lavalier is a lot more affordable. Røde gives you three windscreens for the same price as one from Rycote. The fur protects not only the audio from any wind noise, but also the mic from the first splashes of water.

How to use

  • Download the Røde Rec APP and set sample rate to 48,000 hertz. When back home, export the recordings as a .wav file. Alternatively, use the standard memo app on your smartphone.
  • Invest in a package of Røde Mnifur Lav
  • Set phone on flight mode
  • Position the microphone 20 to 30 cm beneath the talent’s mouth
  • If you want to monitor your audio while recording then you can invest in a Røde SC6 adapter that allows you to plug in headphones while recording
  • Warning: If using this setup in the water, I would strongly advise you bring an extra means of communication in case your smartphone runs out of battery or is dropped accidentally

Pros

  • Reasonably priced
  • Good entry-level mic
  • Picks up little wind noise
  • Monitor audio
  • Cheap accessories

Cons:

  • Not a waterproof mic
  • Drains smartphone battery
  • Touchscreen can be difficult to operate if wet

It is a hassle to record audio out in the field, and you constantly make mistakes, but you also learn something new every time. The real pay-off comes when you present your rugged adventure video without the audience ever noticing the audio.

Thor F. Jensen is an award-winning filmmaker, illustrator and adventurer based in Denmark.

Kokatat’s Polartech Power Dry Liner

Photo: Dawn Mossop
Kokatat’s Polartech Power Dry Liner

Nothing beats a onesie when you’re trying to stay warm. Kokatat’s Polartech Power Dry Liner is a warm, stretchy layer to sandwich between your base layers and drysuit. My favorite feature: the women’s version has a drop seat compatible relief zipper.

Mens: $160, Women’s: $175 | www.kokatat.com

RPv17 rgb

This gear review first appeared in the Spring 2015 issue of Rapid magazine.

 

Video Skill: How to Make a Flip Line

Photo: Screen Capture
Screenshot of a group of whitewater paddlers, with one holding a red flip line.
[iframe width=”560″ height=”315″ src=”https://www.youtube.com/embed/s2y2Bt7l2wE” frameborder=”0″ allowfullscreen ]

From NRS:

“A flip line, or guide belt, made with a length of webbing and a locking carabiner, has many different uses for kayakers, rafters and canoeist. In addition to helping flip an overturned raft, you can use it to make a rescue anchor, boat tether, rescue harness, etc. Swiftwater rescue instructor Jim Coffey shows how to build yours.”

Video Skill: Equipping Your PFD for Rescue

Photo: Screen Capture
Screenshot from this NRS video featuring Jim Coffey showcasing whitewater rescue gear such as a throw bag, pulleys and carabiners and a whitewater pfd.
[“https://www.youtube.com/embed/jd6GL5tmQh0”]
An easy copy and paste to equipping your PFD for Rescue

Whitewater rescue gear should be included in your purchase of a whitewater canoe or kayak as it is only a matter of time before you or your paddling buddies are in a situation that will require some, if not all of what is shown in this video produced by NRS and whitewater guru, Jim Coffey. Not only is it important to own and bring this gear with you on the river, it is important to know how to use it effectively and to ensure that those you paddle with know how to use it as well. As Jim Coffey says “wearing a quick-release rescue PFD is only the beginning of getting prepared for rescue situations on the water. Experienced rescuers equip their life jackets with pulleys, prussics, crib sheets, carabineers and other essential items.”

 

Video Skill: How to Quickly Coil a Throw Rope

[iframe width=”560″ height=”315″ src=”https://www.youtube.com/embed/mcHoXpHi5yU?list=PLqAWcG4wIk6NaN1cOLKXd-a37HHRLAuyk” frameborder=”0″ allowfullscreen ]

From NRS:

“Knowing how to quickly coiling your throw rope for a second toss is an essential swiftwater rescue skill. Here’s a trick to help you make a fast, tangle-free second throw.”

Gear Favorites for a New Season

Gear Favorites for a New Season

With all the new gear and gadgets hitting the water this spring, it’s easy to end up in a daze of bling and cha-ching. As editor of Kayak Angler magazine, I have my pick of the newest and hottest swag. But each season, these five favorites are in my kit and on my kayak…

 

PM FieldTest thumbContinue reading this review in the April 2015 issue of Paddling Magazine, available on your desktopApple or Android device.

 

Video: Learn the Scoop Sea Kayak Rescue

Photo: Screen Capture
Leon Somme helps his paddling partner Shawna Franklin into her sea kayak using the scoop rescue.
[iframe width=”560″ height=”315″ src=”https://www.youtube.com/embed/wE5y_DW2h04?list=UUyNgITuDZ_YWn3BqtBWMxug” frameborder=”0″ allowfullscreen ]

In this episode, presented by Adventure Kayak magazine, Shawna Franklin and Leon Sommé of Body Boat Blade use the “belly down, hug the boat” method as a more stable, easier approach to this rescue. They have also incorporated the super simple “Haggerty Handle” for the rescuer who may struggle to right the victim’s boat. Watch it, then try it!

The scoop rescue is a fast and effective way to get an incapacitated paddler back into their kayak. In this video demonstration, presented by Adventure Kayak magazine, Shawna Franklin and Leon Sommé of Body Boat Bladeuse the “belly down, hug the boat” method as a more stable, easier approach to this rescue. They have also incorporated the super simple “Haggerty Handle” for the rescuer who may struggle to right the victim’s boat. Every variation of sea kayak rescue has its’ own specific application and the scoop rescue is no different. It was developed as one way to assist tired paddlers who had exited their kayaks and were too incapacitated to re-enter under their own power. Utilizing the body weight and natural force of both paddlers, it is a low impact rescue that reduces the chances of muscle strain or continuing paddler fatigue. Watch this video demonstration.

Stay tuned for more skills videos with Body Boat Blade International in this series, presented by Adventure Kayak, and watch more techniques on our YouTube channel. 

Last Paddle on the Dehcho

Photos: Karen McColl
Last Paddle on the Dehcho

As we inch our canoe past the safety of an upstream sandbar and into an onslaught of waves, I panic. “I can’t do this! Let’s turn around!” I shout to Daniel in the bow. He allows me to steer the canoe back to the safety of shore, moments before it would have been too late.

Usually, Daniel and I paddle within about 50 meters of shore when it’s windy, but now we are trapped on an island with least one kilometer of wind-thrashed waves separating us from the shore we need to get to. Daniel wants to go for it, but I’m scared. I shed a few tears of self-pity, then we set up the tent and wait.

Around here, the Mackenzie River calls the shots.

It’s Canada’s longest river and our largest watershed, covering more than one and a half times the land area of Ontario. The year 2014 marked marks the 225-year anniversary since Alexander Mackenzie of the Northwest Company traveled the river with aboriginal guides. Long before his time, this river was known as the Dehcho, or Great River. It connects the Dehcho, Sahtu and Gwich’in First Nation regions (who are, collectively, the Dene people) as well as the Inuvialuit Settlement Region near the Mackenzie Delta.

Visitors, who come from all over the world to paddle the Mackenzie, think of it a great wilderness river, but for the Dene, it’s simply their backyard. It is here they have always hunted, fished and traveled.

 

Dan_and_I_KMcColl_copy.jpg

 

That backyard could be changing. Oil and gas interests are picking up in the central valley area, and an extension of the Mackenzie Valley all-season road may soon be penetrating deeper into its boreal forest and muskeg, providing easier access to the region for local First Nations and developers alike. The Mackenzie River may always be big and powerful, but it might not always be the place it is today.

I’m canoeing with Daniel Campbell, a friend-of-a-friend who hails from this territory’s capital. We put in a few days upstream of Wrigley, N.W.T. and our end destination is Inuvik, more than 1,000 kilometers downstream.

On our second day, we get a visit from Jonas and Tony, two Dene men from Willowlake River. Daniel and I had just finished unloading our barrels and bags onto a beautiful sand bar next to a creek when they cut the engine of their jet boat and drift to shore. They are going hunting for a night or two, Jonas explains, but I notice their boat is mostly empty apart from a couple of guns and some snacks. They plan to curl up on the rocks under the stars—no tent, no sleeping pad—says Jonas, as he eyes our pile of bags and barrels.

Tony doesn’t speak English but Jonas tells us Tony’s aunt is buried across the creek, where we noticed a small fenced area. Tony sits in the boat smiling, his blue eyes twinkling when I offer them chocolate. Then they’re off again, into the dusky horizon of a sun reluctant to set.

It’s hot when we arrive in Wrigley and hit the empty streets in search of a place to fill our water jugs. Today is Canada Day and everything is closed, but we have the good fortune of meeting the water truck driver on his driveway. He fills up our jug straight from his truck while his girlfriend brings us a bag of ice from inside the house Katy points at houses down the street, showing us where her parents, grandparents and cousins live, all within shouting distance.

Wrigley is the northern terminus of the Mackenzie Highway, a gravel road completed in 1994 that links the tiny community of 150 people to the Alberta border. It’s a quiet place, but Wrigley’s relative isolation may change when it’s no longer at the end of the road. The 333-kilometer highway extension north to Norman Wells is in the planning stages, with the overall goal being to extend it all the way to the Dempster Highway near Inuvik.

The highway will be built over the existing winter road, which parallels the Mackenzie River in several places. As we pass the fish-filled tributaries downriver, I imagine what it would be like to pass a family picnicking on the gravel bar or a bunch of anglers in their waders. Or worse, the plumes of dust that are sure to follow every driver on these dry gravel roads.

The Mackenzie River is already far from untouched: there are signs of humans everywhere. We don’t see jet boats whizzing by, barges transporting supplies up and down the valley and rustic cabins dotting the shore between the six communities we visit.

 

Young_girl_in_Wrigley_KMcColl_copy.jpg

 

I consider the Mackenzie River a low-risk, high-consequence river. It’s so slow and sluggish, it would be almost hard to capsize a canoe during calm weather. But if did happen, it would be extremely dangerous. The river is consistently more than a kilometer wide and it’s frigid—so cold I couldn’t bring myself to take a dip on even the hottest days.

Daniel and I are almost sun-blind when we land in Tulita, a community of 500 people located on a bank above the mouth of the crystal clear Great Bear River.

Our next community is the oil town of Norman Wells. By now we are able to cover 60 to 80 kilometers a day, so the 78-kilometer paddle between Norman Wells and Tulita would be a piece of cake to cover in two days, without the nasty head wind that makes us work for each stroke. Strong winds are normal around “the Wells,” where the river widens to more than five kilometers across.

I knew about the Wells before arriving was that Imperial oil had been drilling here since the 1920s, so I wasn’t expecting much in terms of scenery. It was a pleasant surprise to find that the community of 700 or so people has a beautiful mountain backdrop, even though the closest slope has been chewed away by a giant quarry. This boom and bust town is a halfway point for many paddlers, because of its location and amenities. Unlike Wrigley and Tulita, Norman Wells has a couple of restaurants and watering holes, as well as the last liquor store for 700 kiometers.

The weather is bad on departure day, so Daniel and I drag breakfast and lunch out until 3 p.m., when the water has calmed significantly. Soon after we get on the river the wind dies and the water turns to glass. It’s a beyond perfect evening.

“Is that smoke?”

It’s close to 11 p.m. and time to look for a place to camp. As we get closer to shore, we notice a few trees burning. It is smoke! We decide we should camp on the large island on our left to avoid the smouldering fire but we see a black bear swim across the channel and onto that same island. Five-hundred meters downriver, a dozen or so tents dot the shore. It’s a group of voyageur canoeists, whom we met the previous day. They are usually on the water by 6 a.m., they told us, hence the reason they are already sleeping. We watch the bear wander into the forest and, satisfied it isn’t going to bother the group, keep going. Daniel and I find a spot downriver that is smoky but bear-free.

The ramparts is an area just upstream of Fort Good Hope where the Mackenzie River narrows exponentially as it flows between 90-metre high limestone cliffs. There are some rapids at the entrance to the narrows, but following the advice of our guidebook, we stayed right and avoided them altogether.

Not so much for Chris Miele, a solo paddler who arrived in Inuvik a few days after Daniel and me. The 25-year-old was moving from Vancouver, B.C., to Iceland to start a master’s degree, and brought everything he needed for school down the river, packed in suitcases. Following the advice of a hunter, Chris went left through the Ramparts, which our guidebook says only to do at high water. The river was extremely low and Chris went over a three-foot ledge that filled his canoe with water. Miraculously, his boat didn’t tip and he was eventually expelled from the swirling water and able to slowly make his way to shore. Perhaps more amazingly, he didn’t lose anything in the process.

 

Sign_in_Tulita_KMcColl_copy.jpg

 

High above the river in Fort Good Hope a large cross commemorates a small church built over 20 years starting in 1865. The inside is painted with outrageously bright colors made from fish oil and adorned with two paintings by the prolific northern artist Bern Will Brown, a former priest who lived in nearby Colville Lake until his death earlier this year.

Two paddlers I met in Inuvik told me they got engaged in this church. Considering that a canoe is often jokingly referred to as a divorce boat, I’m guessing that any relationship that survives a multi-week canoe trip is likely to last.

While touring the church, Daniel and I meet the ever-hospitable Sisters Joan and Pauline, who feed us one of the best meals of trip and cordially beat us at their favorite card game.

It’s during the seven-day stretch to Tsiigehtchic that Daniel and I get stuck on an island in a windstorm. After 24-hours, there’s a break in the weather.

“Time to go!” Daniel says excitedly. Without another word, we break camp and throw our gear in the canoe, allowing ourselves to cheer as we shoved off. There’s nothing like a day spent on a wind-scoured sand bar to make one go a little stir-crazy.

The next few days are rainy and windy, so it’s a welcome sight when we round a bend and see a white steeple illuminated by a ray of sun poking through the clouds in Tsiigehtchic. After visiting this friendly Gwich’in community of less than 200 people, we slog through the east channel of the Mackenzie Delta to arrive in Inuvik, our final destination. We can hear the town of about 3,500 people before we can see it: airplanes zip in and out of the airport, high-end jet boats blow past us and the deafening drone of the diesel generator reverberates upriver.

The Canadian Government planned and built Inuvik from scratch in the ’50s and although it’s small in population by southern standards, it has lots of things we haven’t seen in a while: a recreation center, large hotels and a full-sized grocery store. As we walk down the street past locals and other tourists, some speaking German and French, no one remarks on our arrival or waves from their passing truck. No one offers us a ride from the dock up to the campground either. For the first time in weeks, I am just another person in a sea of strangers. Our canoe trip on the Dehcho has come to an end.

—Karen McColl has been freelance writing since 2009 and has written for the CBC, the Globe and Mail, the Toronto Star, Outpost magazine, Up Here and Up Here Business magazines—

 

Screen_Shot_2015-03-25_at_11.19.31_AM.png

This article first appeared in the April issue of Paddling Magazine.

Gear: Best Wood Burning Stoves

Photo: Flickr user/Thomas' Pics
Gear: Best Wood Burning Stoves

Most of today’s self-propelled campers rely on liquid-fueled (propane, butane, gasoline, alcohol) stoves for all their cooking. But there’s a hardcore minority who prefer the lightweight and reliability of wood. Admittedly, I haven’t always been a big fan of wood-burning trail stoves. That said, I almost always bring one on my canoeing and camping trips. It keeps the kettle boiling, saves liquid fuel and provides heat and ambience when I don’t have a campfire. And it’s useful for burning trash—important on a long trip where packing garbage can attract animals.

In my opinion, the three trail stoves reviewed here represent the best of the breed. All are efficient, lightweight, sturdy, compact and beautifully made. What’s best for you depends on the style in which you travel—how light you want to go and whether you plan to use a liquid-fueled stove for some of your cooking. As a bonus, all of these stoves can be fueled with alcohol, heat tabs or Sterno.

Advantages of wood-burning stoves over models that burn liquid fuel include:

  • No fuel to buy or carry
  • Usually lighter and more compact than liquid-fuel models, and takes less space in a pack
  • Gives off warming heat and can double as a small campfire

The disadvantages are:

  • You must collect the wood it burns. Collecting wood can be illegal.
  • In many places, they are not a legal substitute for a liquid-fuel stove. They are never legal anywhere during a fire-ban.
  • Most won’t accept sizeable logs, especially with a pot on top. You must constantly feed the beast.
  • Blackens pots, which can result in soiled gear and hands.

CONSIDERATIONS

  • WEIGHT: Generally, the lighter the better—the stove must be sturdy enough to support a heavy pot.
  • HEIGHT VS. DIAMETER: Height increases the chimney effect and burning efficiency. But a too high stove can be tippy. A wide opening will accept thicker sticks than a narrow opening. Stoves that accept only small sticks require constant feeding.
  • BASE (floor): A base keeps hot coals from burning the ground. A separate (removable) base is more versatile than an integral one. Why? Because with use, the building ash clogs the vent holes and reduces the air flow. Eventually, the stove shuts down. You may have to extinguish the stove and invert it to clear the ashes. If the base is separate (mini-fire pan) you can lift the stove and shake out the ash from the bottom. 
  • SPEED OF ASSEMBLY: All the stoves reviewed here are fast and easy to assemble. The Trek Stov leads the pack at just five seconds.
  • STABILITY: All these stoves will support heavy pots. Very wide kettles and heavy sticks that are much longer than the stove is high, adversely affect stability.

STOVES: 

32.LittlbugStove.jpeg

LITTLBUG Sr. and Jr.

The Littlbug Senior and Junior are identical except for size (see table below). The stoves are ingeniously simple—just snap two stainless steel halves together. The stove’s near zero thickness takes up almost no space at all in a pack; the rounded half-shape nests tightly against a rolled sleeping pad or the inside wall of a barrel. The stove can be used with or without its pot supports. Without them, it will accept logs nearly as large as its diameter. With them and a pot on top, the openings are smaller—2.5 or 4.0 inches, depending on the model. Long logs can be stacked “inverted tipi” style around the pot, creating quite a blaze—and enough heat to double as a roaring campfire. 

The pot supports can be lowered to fire the stove with alcohol or Sterno. The unit can be used as a windscreen for a commercial alcohol burner or a liquid fuel stove. An ultralight (optional) folding “Fire-bowl” base contains ashes and makes dumping them a breeze—or just use a pizza pan. If you’re camping on snow, the stove can be suspended from a branch with the lightweight chain set provided. Sounds goofy but it works great even with heavy pots. I seldom go on a trip without a Littlbug stove. www.littlbug.com.

 

Screen_Shot_2015-03-24_at_5.13.04_PM.pngTREK STOV

The Trek Stove has three parts: the lid, which provides ventilation and doubles as a fire pan, the double-wall stove body, and the pot support ring.  Assembly is almost instantaneous. The double-walled stove body has small vent holes around the inside top. There are larger holes at the bottom. The two sets of vent holes and double-wall construction permit fast starts and very clean burning.  Wood seems to burn hotter, more slowly and more efficiently in this stove than in the others in our sample. A wide U-shaped opening in the pot support ring allows entry of fairly thick sticks. The stove will accept wood up to about two inches in diameter if there’s no pot on top.  Add a pot and you must halve the diameter of the fuel. There’s an ash screen at the bottom. Ashes fall into the base (which becomes the cover when the stove is packed).

Lift the stove off the base to dump the ashes (requires some effort if the stove is hot and choked with ash). There’s a 1.5 inch diameter hole in the center of the base: The battery operated fan of a Sierra Zip stove can be inserted into that hole. The fan turns the Trek Stov into a veritable blow torch! The Trek Stove is remarkably engineered and a work of art.  It is the most sturdy, easiest to assemble and most sophisticated stove in our sample. It is also the heaviest and bulkiest. Unlike the other stoves here, it won’t blacken your hands when you take it apart to pack it away. http://www.nimbuskayaks.com/Trek%20stove.htm.   

       

IMGP0127.jpeg

EMBERLIT STOVE

Constructed from ultralight titanium or stainless steel, the EmberLIt is the most compact stove in our sample. Five “playing card thin” pieces—four sides and a base—snap together with ease and precision.  With practice, assembly takes only about 30 seconds.  When packed, this tiny stove consumes about as much space as a large post card. The little stove is remarkably strong for its weight–it easily supported my 20 pound Dutch oven! You must insert two titanium cross-bars provided (it takes just seconds) when using pots that are smaller than the stove top. The cross bars are used only to support small pots—they are not needed for rigidity.

The Emberlit will accept wood up to about 1.5 inches in diameter with a pot on top or 3.5 inches without a pot.  You can fuel it from the top or through a port in the side (near the base).  This is the only stove in our sample that can be fueled and lit from the side. The others must be lit from the top or through a vent hole near the bottom, which can be awkward. The EmberLIt develops a fast efficient draft, but wood burns quickly—you must keep feeding it. Though fairly thick sticks can be loaded through the top of the stove, they must be short—ones that are too long will unbalance and topple the stove. Very long sticks may be loaded through the side port but you must “keep “pushing” them forward as they burn. The EmberLit shines best for preparing quick meals where its run time is short. It’s not designed to double as a campfire. www.emberlit.com

 

CLIFF’S RECOMMENDATIONS

  • For going ultralight, preparing fast meals, and where bulk and weight are prime concerns, I recommend the Littlbug Jr. and EmberLit Stove
  • For long burning times and stability with large wood, plus puts out enough heat to double as a campfire, I recommend the Littlbug Senior.
  • For maximum fuel efficiency and instant assembly, go with the Trek Stov.

SPECS COMPARED

  LITTLBUG JR. LITTLBUG SR. TREK STOV EmberLit STOVE
Weight (oz) 5.0 19 24 5.5 titanium / 11.3 SS
Packed size (inches) 7.0 x 5.0 x 1/16 11 x 7 x 1/16 4.5 x.4.5 x 6.0 6.0 x 5.0 x 1/16
Assembled size/inches 5.4 x 6.3 8.0” x 9.0” 8.25 x 5.1 x 8.4 6.0 x 5.0 x 5.0

Largest opening (inches): suggests size of largest diameter wood it will accept.

2.5 with pot on top or 6.0 without pot

4.0 with pot or 8.0

without /pot

2.5 with pot

4.1 without pot

1.5 with pot

3.5 without pot.

Base:

Optional folding “Fire-bowl”

3.8 oz

Optional folding

“Fire-bowl”

7.4 oz

Removable Integral
Constructed from Stainless steel Stainless steel Stainless steel Titanium/stainless steel
Ease/speed of Assembly/disassembly 20 seconds 20 seconds 5 seconds 30 seconds

Stability with a wide, heavy pot on top:

1= Solid, like a rock!

2 =Very stable

3 =Acceptably stable

3 3 1

2

Fit, finish and quality of construction Excellent Excellent Excellent Excellent
Carrying case provided Yes Yes No Yes

 

Cliff Jacobson is a wilderness canoeing and camping consultant and the author of over a dozen top-selling books on camping and canoeing. His video, The Forgotten Skills, details the most important campcraft procedures. He is a Distinguished Eagle Scout and a recipient of the American Canoe Association’s Legends of Paddling awardhttp://cliff-jacobson.com